Wednesday, October 1, 2008

Blog Reflection No. 4 - Print Vs. Electronic Resources

Comparing Print vs. Electronic resources, I would choose Printed Resources hands down. Why? Because as wonderful as Electronic Resources are, computers do have their downtime, restrictions (e.g., membership requirements), and not everyone has access to a computer. You cannot check out a computer like you can a book. You are more likely to have access to Printed Resources than to Electronic Resources. I feel each has its place and serves the patron according to their needs at a specific time.

Risking the chance of sounding as though I’m straddling both sides of the fence, I would have to say I would evaluate both and opt for a balance. Logically speaking, this money has to be extra because budgets are usually based on previously planned needs for the year. With that assumption, if I had an extra $5,000 to enhance my reference collection, I would still focus my purchases on the needs of the community. I'm going to back-paddle here a little bit by saying we are at a disadvantage here not knowing the cost of various reference collections or electronic reference materials. But if I did, I feel certain I would choose an addition that would take my electronic materials to another level, which would probably use up the entire sum. In the case of affordable printed material, perhaps a collection I felt I would never be able to purchase through a planned yearly budget.

Reflecting on my own usage of electronic vs. print resources, I don’t think print resources are becoming obsolete in lieu of electronic resources. There are times when it is more convenient for me to spend time at the library and use their print reference materials. Personally, I prefer it. Many reference materials are not accessible online due to required membership. I feel library collections are best used in a library environment instead of online with the exception of quick reference material (standard dictionaries/encyclopedias, etc.). I have yet to be satisfied interacting with virtual help sources (Yahoo, etc.)...if you have a problem, good luck...they don't want you to find them it seems. It is different with our LBCC support, I always get immediate response with a live person and my problem gets solved. I've been told communicating with reference staff through Side Road leaves the student empty handed. I have not yet tried virtual reference staff, but I will.

2 comments:

DJ said...

Regarding virtual help - I totally agree! When I need help online, the FAQ's rarely answer my questions, but websites are commonly set up so that you have to go through the FAQ process before you can even email anyone with the problem you have.

I often find a sort of language barrier between me and online/email tech service associates. I often can't communicate the question I have in a way that they seem to understand what the problem is - Maybe they should learn about the reference interview too! :}

MedicalLibTech said...

Wow. It is so nice to hear that someone out there agrees with me. I've heard from patrons in my library say "soon there will not be any use for print" which I think is bologna. Electronic resources can be useful but there are so many barriers – not everyone has a computer readily available, the cost/licensing of e-books can be daunting and there are so many people out there who are afraid of computers. Print will always be needed and wanted. 